# Sibyl UX/QoL Round 2

Run: `run-2026-06-04-sibyl-ux-qol-round2`

This run repeats the first-user CLI path and adds focused probes for migration/backup UX, free-tier cap UX, and ambiguous memory requests.

## Verdict

`NEEDS_UX_PATCHES`

## Findings

| Severity | Area | Issue | Suggested fix |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| medium | Authentication / init UX | `sibyl init --help` does not explain the email + verification-code flow or what happens next. | Expand init help with one short paragraph and a post-login success/next-step message. |
| medium | Ambiguous memory UX | Vague memory questions returned no useful search context instead of prompting for clarification. | Skill pack rule: if memory query lacks entity and intent confidence is low, call AskUserQuestion before searching. |

## CLI Commands

| Command | Return code |
| --- | ---: |
| help | 0 |
| init_help | 0 |
| setup_help | 0 |
| migrate_help | 0 |
| status_clean_home | 0 |
| health_clean_home | 0 |
| whoami_clean_home | 1 |
| setup_codex_dry_run | 0 |
| migrate_happy_path | 0 |
| migrate_backup_path_is_file | 0 |

## Ambiguous Memory Searches

| Query | Hits | Keys |
| --- | ---: | --- |
| What should I focus on this week? | 0 |  |
| Who owns this now? | 0 |  |
| What changed recently? | 0 |  |
| What should I focus on for the supermarket rollout this week? | 0 |  |
| Who owns the checkout project now? | 0 |  |

## Free-Tier Cap Probe

- Writes before first failure: `71`
- First failure index: `72`
- DB size bytes: `2732032`

## Artifacts

- Raw result: `runs/run-2026-06-04-sibyl-ux-qol-round2.raw_result.json`